Skip to content
    • About CED
    • Academics
    • For Students
    • CED
      • About CED
        • Community + Values
        • People at CED
        • Meet CED Alums
        • Our Spaces
        • Our History
        • Work at CED
        • Giving
        • Contact Us
      • Academics
        • Undergraduate Majors + Minors
        • Graduate Programs
        • Concurrent Graduate Degrees
        • Certificates
        • Summer Programs
        • Study Abroad
      • Admissions
        • Undergraduate Admissions
        • Graduate Admissions
        • Fees + Financial Aid
      • Undergraduate Advising
        • Newly Admitted Students
        • Forms + Policies
        • Major + Minor Requirements
        • Prepare for Graduation
        • Academic Progress Report
      • News + Events
        • News
        • Events
      • Research + Design
        • Affiliated Research Centers
        • Climate Solutions
        • Equity + Social Justice
        • Technology + Material Innovations
        • Design Excellence
        • Publications
        • Environmental Design Archives
        • Student Work
      • Student Resources
        • Student Organizations
        • Student Support
        • Awards, Scholarships, Fellowships
        • Academic Student Employment
        • Student Fees and Waivers
        • IT + Computing
        • Fabrication + Materials
        • Environmental Design Library
        • Building Safety
        • Facility Services
        • Careers + Opportunities
    • ARCH
      • About Architecture
        • Commitment to Diversity
        • Accreditation and Licensure
      • People
      • Degrees + Admissions
        • Master of Architecture (MArch)
        • Master of Advanced Architectural Design (MAAD)
        • Master of Science in Architecture
        • PhD in Architecture
        • Bachelor of Arts
        • Minors
      • Gallery
      • Courses
      • Advising
    • LAND
      • About LAEP
      • People
      • Degrees + Admissions
        • Master of Landscape Architecture
        • PhD
        • Bachelor of Arts
        • Minor in Landscape Architecture
      • Gallery
      • Advising
    • CITY
      • About DCRP
      • People
      • Degrees + Admissions
        • Master of City Planning
        • PhD
        • Bachelor of Arts in Urban Studies
        • Minor in City Planning
        • Minor in Geospatial Information Science & Technology
      • Gallery
      • Advising
    • IURD
      • About IURD
      • People
      • IURD Research Projects
      • Abbey Master of Real Estate Development + Design (MRED+D)
        • About Abbey MRED+D
        • Abbey MRED+D Admissions
        • Abbey MRED+D Courses
        • People
      • Master of Urban Design (MUD)
        • People
      • BA in Sustainable Environmental Design
      • Advising
  • CED
    • About CED
      • Community + Values
      • People at CED
      • Meet CED Alums
      • Our Spaces
      • Our History
      • Work at CED
      • Giving
      • Contact Us
    • Academics
      • Undergraduate Majors + Minors
      • Graduate Programs
      • Concurrent Graduate Degrees
      • Certificates
      • Summer Programs
      • Study Abroad
    • Admissions
      • Undergraduate Admissions
      • Graduate Admissions
      • Fees + Financial Aid
    • Undergraduate Advising
      • Newly Admitted Students
      • Forms + Policies
      • Major + Minor Requirements
      • Prepare for Graduation
      • Academic Progress Report
    • News + Events
      • News
      • Events
    • Research + Design
      • Affiliated Research Centers
      • Climate Solutions
      • Equity + Social Justice
      • Technology + Material Innovations
      • Design Excellence
      • Publications
      • Environmental Design Archives
      • Student Work
    • Student Resources
      • Student Organizations
      • Student Support
      • Awards, Scholarships, Fellowships
      • Academic Student Employment
      • Student Fees and Waivers
      • IT + Computing
      • Fabrication + Materials
      • Environmental Design Library
      • Building Safety
      • Facility Services
      • Careers + Opportunities
  • ARCH
    • About Architecture
      • Commitment to Diversity
      • Accreditation and Licensure
    • People
    • Degrees + Admissions
      • Master of Architecture (MArch)
      • Master of Advanced Architectural Design (MAAD)
      • Master of Science in Architecture
      • PhD in Architecture
      • Bachelor of Arts
      • Minors
    • Gallery
    • Courses
    • Advising
  • LAND
    • About LAEP
    • People
    • Degrees + Admissions
      • Master of Landscape Architecture
      • PhD
      • Bachelor of Arts
      • Minor in Landscape Architecture
    • Gallery
    • Advising
  • CITY
    • About DCRP
    • People
    • Degrees + Admissions
      • Master of City Planning
      • PhD
      • Bachelor of Arts in Urban Studies
      • Minor in City Planning
      • Minor in Geospatial Information Science & Technology
    • Gallery
    • Advising
  • IURD
    • About IURD
    • People
    • IURD Research Projects
    • Abbey Master of Real Estate Development + Design (MRED+D)
      • About Abbey MRED+D
      • Abbey MRED+D Admissions
      • Abbey MRED+D Courses
      • People
    • Master of Urban Design (MUD)
      • People
    • BA in Sustainable Environmental Design
    • Advising
  • About CED
  • Academics
  • For Students
  • About CED
  • Academics
  • For Students
BACK
BACK
WORK

A Modest Proposal: Adapting To Sea Level Rise

Over the next 50 to 75 years, the shore of the San Francisco Bay is going to change rather dramatically. Like every other coastal region of the world, the Bay Area will be adapting to sea level rise. This phenomenon is in large part a legacy of past CO2 emissions, meaning that the rate of sea level rise is going to accelerate even if we were to stop producing CO2 today. We face a “train wreck” of lost wetlands and lost biodiversity if we build seawalls, or an insurance nightmare of flooded properties without structural protections.

Most academics are calling for stronger governance and adaptive management in order to protect wetlands, roads and buildings, but my research is taking a different approach. Given that American property law leaves so many rights to property owners, relative to other countries of the world, we might better consider an adaptation strategy for sea level rise that aligns the interests of developers and conservationists. My question is, what would that kind of “hybrid edge” look like, and could it function ecologically and economically?

Federal funds for adaptation will most likely go to cities where disasters occur. We may have a major fire or earthquake, but we’re not likely to experience a hurricane triggering emergency funds that could bankroll our coastal adaptation. Therefore, we need to fund it regionally, using our increasing private land values. As the rest of the U.S. experiences extreme weather events, the Bay Area may be buffered from many heat and rain events by our coastal fog and our mild weather—although the Central Valley could potentially be hit with major floods, and we will all surely need to adapt to drought.

So what could a hybrid edge look like that would align the interests of environmentalists and developers around the Bay? What if we develop the shore with a series of what could be called “micro-polders”—at tens of acres each they would be much smaller than actual Dutch polders. We could surround these micro-polders with water-control levees to keep the water levels steady. We could use them to store floodwater from rain and from the tributaries of the Bay. And we could build housing in them, as the Dutch and increasingly the Germans do, with foundations that extend into the Bay sediments or by floating them inside micro-polders that are kept permanently wet. Around these housing polders we could use clean sediment to raise the bottom of the Bay (a practice called “shallowing”) to construct wetlands for habitat, and to reduce wave energy which is a major component of the hazard associated with sea level rise. We could construct beaches as well, to absorb wave energy and provide for human recreational access to the water. And perhaps best of all, we could use this hybrid edge of micro-polders to protect low-lying inland areas from flooding—using new housing and its associated infrastructure to protect both older housing and the roadways we depend on regionally.

It could work. It is a version of the future that is worth studying, which what I will continue to do. My students and I are planning to use robotic underwater cameras to assess the variety of underwater edge conditions, and are creating visualization tools to help policymakers see how local strategies could add up to this regional re-alignment of interests—to the benefit of us all.

 

Photograph

Housing on pile foundations in infrastructure pond in Rotterdam

Work
MORE INFORMATION

Salt Ponds -- Bay Area

Presentation by Kristina Hill: Adapting Cities to Extreme Flooding Events

Girls scale retaining wall -- New Orleans

Presentation by Kristina Hill: Hybrid Edges: A Typology of Coastal Adaptation Strategies

Photo Modal

Berkeley home page

230 Bauer Wurster Hall #1820 Berkeley, CA 94720-1820

230 Bauer Wurster Hall #1820 | Berkeley, CA 94720-1820

  • Contact
  • Work at CED
  • Faculty + Staff
  • Linkedin
  • Accessibility
  • Land Acknowledgment
  • Privacy
  • Nondiscrimination
  • Credits

© 2025 UC Regents; all rights reserved.

    • DONATE NOW
    • ARCH
    • CITY
    • LAND
    • IURD
Berkeley home page
  • ARCH
  • CITY
  • LAND
  • IURD
  • DONATE NOW
  • Contact
  • Work at CED
  • Faculty + Staff

230 Bauer Wurster Hall #1820 Berkeley, CA 94720-1820

  • Accessibility
  • Land Acknowledgment
  • Privacy
  • Nondiscrimination
  • Credits

© 2025 UC Regents; all rights reserved.